Controversy erupted deep into stoppage time during Celtic’s dramatic 3-2 win away at Motherwell, when referee John Beaton was sent to the pitchside monitor following a VAR intervention in the 97th minute.
Key Points:
- Late VAR intervention in the 97th minute led to a controversial handball penalty for Celtic against Motherwell
- Kelechi Iheanacho converted the decisive spot-kick to seal a 3-2 win, keeping Celtic’s title hopes alive
- Gary Lineker and Kris Boyd strongly criticised the decision, calling it a major VAR error and disputing the handball call
- Chris Sutton defended the officials, insisting the decision was correct and accusing critics of overreacting amid title tension
Late VAR Drama Decides Celtic’s Trip to Motherwell
After reviewing the incident, Beaton awarded a penalty for a handball against Sam Nicholson, who was deemed to have handled the ball with his arm in an unnatural position while contesting a header.
Kelechi Iheanacho calmly converted the resulting spot-kick, sealing a crucial victory for Martin O’Neill’s side. The win puts Celtic in position to clinch the Scottish Premiership title with a final-day showdown against Hearts, though the manner of the decision has sparked widespread debate.
Pundits Slam Decision as VAR Debate Intensifies
The call quickly drew backlash from across the football world, with Gary Lineker among the first to question the decision on social media. “This might be the worst VAR decision I've seen (and there's a lot of competition)," Lineker wrote. "Extraordinary given the significance."
Former Rangers striker Kris Boyd also heavily criticised the incident, arguing that the physics of the play suggested the ball made contact with Nicholson’s head rather than his arm. "If you throw a ball at someone and it hits your hand, it will drop a couple of yards in front of you," Boyd said during his analysis on Sky Sports.
He also pointed to the fact that the ball eventually went out for a throw-in, using it as further evidence that no handball had occurred. "It is impossible - impossible - to get that distance on a header like that if it's hitting your hand first. It's impossible."
Sutton Hits Back and Defends Officials
Former Celtic striker Chris Sutton defended the decision and the match officials, suggesting that criticism had gone too far following the controversial incident. "Now the dust has settled... the reaction from many high profile people is way over the top," Sutton posted.
He explained that Beaton followed VAR advice and judged the incident based on the arm position, adding: "John Beaton was advised to go to the monitor and saw that the ball hit the arm in an unnatural position. Bottom line is people would hate to see Celtic win the title again and that is all."
Sutton also directly responded to Lineker’s criticism, stating: "It's what VAR is there for," while joking about Boyd’s reaction: "I'm worried Boydy may explode."
Title Race Headed for Final-Day Decider
The controversy has significant implications for the Scottish Premiership title race, with Hearts still firmly in contention for their first league title outside the Old Firm since 1985.
Hearts strengthened their position with a 3-0 win over Falkirk, but Iheanacho’s late penalty means they must now avoid defeat against Celtic at Celtic Park on Saturday to secure the championship.
Hearts manager Derek McInnes expressed strong frustration over the decision, calling it “such a bad decision” and adding: "Motherwell must feel totally aggrieved. I had to keep looking at it because I thought I was missing something. When I was watching it I had to ask 'what I am looking for here?' It's actually quite disgusting."
.png)
